In his letter to the churches of Galatia, Paul described the law as a “schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ.” What did he mean by schoolmaster?
allanswart via Getty Images
Did you ever have a babysitter watch over you when you were a child? Perhaps you’ve been a babysitter yourself at some point, or perhaps you’ve had babysitters watch over your own children.
Most of us in the Western world are quite familiar with the term and the concept. Surprisingly, this knowledge can help us understand an often-misunderstood statement written by the apostle Paul.
That statement in the book of Galatians uses the English word schoolmaster in the King James Version and tutor in the New King James Version to translate a Greek word that is not primarily concerned with teaching. Other translations include guardian (English Standard Version), custodian (Revised Standard Version) and disciplinarian (New Revised Standard Version).
Paul wrote: “Therefore the law was our tutor to bring us to Christ, that we might be justified by faith. But after faith has come, we are no longer under a tutor” (Galatians 3:24-25, NKJV).
Was the law really our schoolmaster?
The word Paul used “is paidagōgos, which means ‘a child-custodian’ or ‘child-attendant.’ The pedagogue was a slave employed by wealthy Greeks or Romans to have responsibility for one of the children of the family” (Expositor’s Bible Commentary, Vol. 10, p. 467).
Had Paul meant “teacher,” he could have used the Greek word didaskalos. He did use this word in other letters to label the important role of teachers in the Church (1 Corinthians 12:28; Ephesians 4:11; 1 Timothy 2:7; 2 Timothy 1:11).
The role of the pedagogue, like that of modern babysitters, was to protect children who had not yet reached maturity. Unlike babysitters, though, these child attendants served continuously rather than occasionally. Frequently pedagogues would watch over children from the time they were 6 until they were 16.
In essence, pedagogues were given the responsibility of overseeing a child to prevent him from making poor decisions that could harm him. It is this supervisory function that Paul highlighted in his metaphor.
What else did Paul say about the law?
Like all Scripture, Paul’s metaphor cannot be fully understood until the context is understood. We need to look at what Paul had already said about law in his letter to the Galatians. Paul uses the word law (nomos) in various ways in his writings, sometimes talking about laws and principles in general, and sometimes talking about specific sets of laws.
Just a few verses before talking about the law being a “schoolmaster” or “tutor,” Paul described this law in an unusual way. He wrote that it was “added because of transgressions” (Galatians 3:19).
This should lead us to ask, “What transgressions, and when did they occur?”
Transgressions refer to breaches of law. Paul himself, in his letter to the church at Rome, wrote that “where there is no law there is no transgression” (Romans 4:15).
On the one hand, Paul wrote about the law being added because of transgressions. On the other hand, Paul wrote that without law, there are no transgressions.
How is this possible?
The law that was added because of transgressions could not have been the great moral law that defines sin (1 John 3:4). It must have been another law altogether. So, what law is being referred to?
What law did Paul describe as a “schoolmaster”?
If we read through the book of Galatians carefully, we can see the thrust of Paul’s reasoning. In the first chapter, he described his own personal history, explaining that he had “persecuted the church of God beyond measure and tried to destroy it” (Galatians 1:13).
He had done so because he had been “zealous for the traditions of [his] fathers” (verse 10). That sort of zeal—clinging to the traditions of their fathers and striving to maintain ritual purity—was apparent in many first-century Jews who had become Christians.
They avoided eating with gentiles—even gentiles who were Christians—because to do so, in their minds, would compromise their ritual purity. Their belief was so strong that they influenced other Christians, including Peter and Barnabas (Galatians 2:11-13).
As a result, Paul publicly rebuked Peter (Galatians 2:14-16), who should have known better. God had already used him to open the door to gentile converts (Acts 10), who received the Holy Spirit while listening to him (verse 44).
What were works of law?
It is in this discussion that Paul provides a glimpse into which law he would later compare to a “schoolmaster.” That glimpse comes from the expression translated “works of the law” (Galatians 2:16).
God’s law defines God’s character, and by extension, it defines sin. It reveals the path of life God desires us to walk.
Unfortunately, many versions of the Bible translate the Greek ergon nomos as “the works of the law,” adding the definite article (“the”) before each noun when it’s not present in the Greek.
What this means is that Paul was not referring to any specific works or to any specific law. “Paul’s emphasis is not on the Jewish law, the law of Moses, at all, though it includes it, but rather on any system of attempting to please God by good deeds. ‘Works of law’ are ‘deeds of men’” (Expositor’s Bible Commentary, Vol. 10, p. 449).
When Paul wrote about works of law, his point was that we are not justified—declared righteous or just—through any such works.
Only God can make us right. Only God can justify us. Justification is accomplished through an act of God, not through any action we can take.
Paul did not write anything negative about God’s law. Instead, he made the point that we cannot be justified through the law. No amount of obedience to the law can ever erase past transgressions. God’s law defines God’s character, and by extension, it defines sin. It reveals the path of life God desires us to walk.
It does not justify.
Were the 10 Commandments “added”?
This brings us back to that unusual statement Paul made about the law that “was added because of transgressions” (Galatians 3:19). The word added is noteworthy. It implies that whatever was added was added to another law already in force.
And as noted earlier, in order for there to be transgressions, God’s moral law, including the 10 Commandments, had to already be in force. They could not be the added law.
We know they already existed because God declared to Isaac that “Abraham obeyed My voice and kept My charge, My commandments, My statutes, and My laws” (Genesis 26:5). In fact, you can find God’s law sprinkled throughout the pages of Genesis, proving that it was known long before Israel assembled at the base of Mount Sinai.
To learn more, read “Were the 10 Commandments Around Before Moses?”
What law was added?
Paul provided the time frame for this addition. It was given 430 years after God’s covenant with Abraham (Galatians 3:16-17).
And it’s interesting to note that the prophet Jeremiah pointed out that the sacrificial law was added after the Exodus—thus 430 years after the covenant with Abraham. Jeremiah recorded God’s words on the lamentable state of His people during the final decades of the nation of Judah. They had paid more attention to sacrificial offerings than to obeying His moral law: “For I did not speak to your fathers, or command them in the day that I brought them out of the land of Egypt, concerning burnt offerings or sacrifices” (Jeremiah 7:22).
One other point that Paul made was that not only did the law come 430 years after God’s covenant with Abraham, but also 430 years after promises He made “to Abraham and his Seed,” whom he identified as Christ.
This is an important point. Jesus, the Seed of Abraham, sacrificed Himself to pay for our sins. It is through that sacrifice that we can be justified. The sacrificial law, on the other hand, governed sacrifices that merely provided “a reminder of sins” (Hebrews 10:3) as they pointed to Christ.
And that brings us back to the main question of this article.
How was the law our “schoolmaster”?
The people of Israel did not keep God’s law. This was not a surprise to God. He knew it and expressed it at Mount Sinai.
His words seem to take on a wistful tone: “Oh, that they had such a heart in them that they would fear Me and always keep all My commandments, that it might be well with them and with their children forever!” (Deuteronomy 5:29).
Like a child under the care of the Greek or Roman pedagogue, or a child being watched by a babysitter, the children of God lacked maturity and did not make the right decisions. They needed the Levitical system including the sacrificial law to remind them that sin has consequences.
They needed to know that sin leads to death.
The Bible holds out hope for Israel (and eventually all people). They would someday be called to conversion and have access to God’s help to obey: “But this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, says the LORD: I will put My law in their minds, and write it on their hearts; and I will be their God, and they shall be My people” (Jeremiah 31:33).
That day could not come until Christ had paid the penalty for our sins (John 16:7). That day came nearly 2,000 years ago, making it possible for God’s people to receive His Holy Spirit.
Instead of having only the graphic shedding of an animal’s lifeblood as a reminder that sin brings death and must be avoided, Christians under the New Covenant are convicted of sin’s seriousness through the work of God’s Spirit (John 16:7-11).
With that Spirit, we can have the spiritual wisdom and discernment that makes a “schoolmaster,” or pedagogue, or babysitter, unnecessary.
Study more about how God writes His law in our hearts and minds in the article “The 10 Commandments for Christians.”