Once primarily an obscure New Age idea, manifesting has become mainstream and some have even tried to “Christianize” it. But is manifestation a biblical idea?
assia
Where do good and positive things in your life come from?
One popular answer is manifestation.
Though it has grown in popularity in recent years through the New Age and self-help movements, its roots go back much further, drawing heavily on Eastern religion and philosophy.
But what exactly is manifesting? Is it compatible with the Bible? And should Christians use manifestation techniques to try to reach their goals and improve their lives?
What is manifesting?
Manifesting is the idea that you can bring success and positive outcomes into your life by deeply and deliberately focusing your thoughts and emotions on what you are trying to achieve or have.
The core idea is that your thoughts and feelings influence your reality. By deliberately directing your mind toward what you desire (often by vividly visualizing it, feeling the emotions of already having it and acting as if it’s already yours), you align yourself with that outcome and “manifest” it into happening.
In this sense, manifesting is attempting to turn a thought or desire into a tangible reality through focused intention.
How does manifestation supposedly work?
According to those who teach manifestation, the power to transform thoughts into reality lies within the mind itself. Many will describe the human mind as having inherent power to shape reality. Thoughts are viewed as energy that creates reality.
“Thoughts become things. If you see it in your mind, you will hold it in your hand.” That’s the saying commonly attributed to Bob Proctor (1934-2022), author of You Were Born Rich.
Those who teach manifesting will usually break it down into four basic techniques:
- Visualize what you want in detail.
- Speak positive affirmations that articulate precisely what you want or what you desire to be.
- Create a vision board (a collage) with imagery of what you desire, and look at it daily.
- Act and conduct yourself as if you already have what you desire.
So, for instance, if a woman has the goal of getting married and having a family with two children, she would:
- Create a clear mental image of that future family and think about it often.
- Speak affirmations such as “I am deserving of love,” “I will meet my future spouse at the perfect time,” and “I am grateful for the family I will have,” and try to generate the feeling of being loved, as if she already has this family.
- Construct a vision board that includes pictures of happy couples and families that she can look at and then visualize those families as being her own.
- Think, feel and speak as if she has already found her spouse and they have children.
The idea of manifesting is closely connected to other popular philosophies, such as the Law of Attraction.
The Law of Attraction attempts to explain how manifesting works by teaching that thoughts create energy that emanates into the universe, and that those thoughts act like magnets, attracting positive or negative energy back in kind.
Help does not come from the universe or from powers within us. It comes from the God who made us and the universe.
So, suppose a person sends positive thoughts into the universe (“I will get married and live happily ever after”). In that case, he or she would magnetically attract positive energy back—“attracting” the marriage and family the person desired.
This idea was popularized by the book The Secret, which was later adapted into a movie.
(To examine the biblical perspective on this philosophy, read “Is the Law of Attraction Biblical?”)
While some manifestation teachings, like this one, present the universe as the source of positive consequences, others attribute them to the inherent power of the human mind. And some subtly present it in biblical terms—as a human power that comes from God.
Manifestation presented as a “Christian” idea
In recent years, some within the mainstream Christian community have attempted to syncretize manifestation philosophy and techniques with biblical concepts.
For instance, some openly claim to teach “Christian manifestation techniques” or to be a “Christian manifestation coach.”
However, sometimes the ideas are presented more subtly, using scriptural or religious language to obscure and distance them from obvious New Age or metaphysical terminology.
Here are some examples of popular books that have done this:
- The Secret Power of Speaking God’s Word, by Joyce Meyer. One of the video presentations connected with this book explains her teaching this way: “Your words hold incredible power! Today, Joyce reveals how the things you say can impact your life in profound ways. Learn how to align your words with God’s truth to create the positive change you’ve been looking for.” The basic premise is to use Scripture as the source of positive affirmation statements. The idea is that you will receive the blessings you want by speaking scriptures about them.
- You Can, You Will and The Power of I Am, by Joel Osteen. In the first book, Mr. Osteen teaches that visualization techniques are key to unlocking your potential and that the gifts already inherent in you can be activated by envisioning who you want to be and maintaining a positive mindset. In the second book, Mr. Osteen presents affirmations as a way of receiving the blessings God wants for you. His Amazon book description gives these examples: “So, when you go through the day saying: ‘I am blessed’ . . . blessings pursue you. ‘I am talented’ . . . talent follows you. ‘I am healthy’ . . . health heads your way. ‘I am strong’ . . . strength tracks you down.”
- The Law of Confession, by Bill Winston. In this book, Mr. Winston uses the biblical term confession to teach his idea that our spoken words (or confessions) shape our reality. So, suppose you want to manifest a specific biblical principle. In that case, you confess the principle out loud and then meditate on it—and the principle will eventually be manifested into your life.
The truth is that these teachers are subtly using biblical language to disguise New Age philosophies.
- Faith and belief are reframed as a powerful force you can tap into to achieve your dreams and desires.
- Prayer is taught as a way to declare your desires in order to receive them.
- Meditation is framed as the practice of focusing your mind on your intended goal or desire.
- Gratitude is presented as a way to shift your focus from negative to positive by generating the feeling of already having what you desire, creating the emotional frequency that supposedly brings it into reality.
- Claiming God’s promises is used to describe the process of manifesting the positive things you desire. These verbal declarations of the promises you wish to receive substitute for affirmations.
- Positive thinking is imbued with the power to achieve desires.
- Blessings are equated with the things one desires to have, and that can be manifested through the mind or the universe.
Using biblical language in place of New Age terms can lead sincere people to adopt unbiblical ideas without realizing it, believing they are practicing something rooted in Scripture.
The key to avoiding these subtle substitutions is not just recognizing the original ideas but also developing a strong understanding of biblical terms in their proper scriptural context.
Beware of misusing biblical terms
Biblical positivity, vision, gratitude and meditation are not techniques for manifesting our desires. In Scripture, these are virtues and spiritual disciplines to help us look to God and build His character.
Instead of being positive in order to “send out good energy” and attract desired outcomes, be positive because it is a key to thinking like your Creator (Philippians 4:8).
Instead of developing a “vision” to manifest your desires, set clear goals that align with God’s will. Then direct your preparation, focus and effort toward accomplishing these goals instead of aimlessly floating through life.
Instead of practicing gratitude for things you don’t yet have in order to “bring them into reality,” be thankful to God for His blessings as an expression of sincere appreciation (1 Thessalonians 5:18).
Instead of meditating to visualize your desires into existence, meditate to fix your mind on God—His Word, His ways and His truth (Psalm 119:97-99).
The Bible contains a treasury of wisdom for success and growth—both physical and spiritual. Christians do not need to look to distorted New Age ideas or Eastern spirituality for guidance.
Why manifestation and the Bible are incompatible
There are two core biblical problems with manifestation philosophies.
First, the idea of manifestation holds that the brain emits energy or frequencies that can interact with the universe and shape reality. However, this idea is not only lacking scientific support—it has no basis in Scripture.
Though the human mind is a remarkable creation of God, the Bible shows that it influences the physical world only through the body’s actions. (To learn more about the amazing human mind, read “What Does the Bible Say About the Mind?” and “The Miracle in the Mind.”)
God is described as having the inherent power to change reality through merely His thoughts or words (Genesis 1:3; Psalm 33:6-9; Hebrews 1:3; 11:3).
The idea that human beings can shape reality through their thoughts or emotions is a subtle attempt to give humankind an ability that belongs to God. It is simply another example of humanity’s recurring effort to assume divine powers apart from God.
Second, manifestation is almost entirely built on personal desires. It is about bending the universe to your will to get what you desire or to fulfill your dreams. Much of manifesting literature appeals to the human proclivity toward covetousness and ease—by promising simple and mystical techniques to achieve what you want.
But God’s way of life, as revealed in the Bible, is not centered on manifesting and receiving your dreams, but obeying the will of God and aligning your life with His purpose for you. That purpose is not necessarily individual and based on your own dreams, but is based on living in faithful obedience to His way of life.
To explore this further, read “Does God Have a Specific Will for Your Life?”
The biblical approach to achieving your goals
The Bible isn’t against our having goals or striving for personal achievement—as long as those goals don’t contradict God’s law. God wants His people to pursue excellence and to succeed in their endeavors.
But the biblical path to success is not mystical or metaphysical. It’s practical and disciplined:
1. Set goals and plan.
Goal setting isn’t a “manifesting technique”; it is a tool to help us direct our decisions and efforts toward achieving our objectives. Goals help us make decisions and plans that align with our purpose. Proverbs 21:5 teaches, “The plans of the diligent lead surely to abundance” (English Standard Version). And Matthew 6:33 encourages us to “seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness” as the basis for setting Christian goals.
2. Seek education and preparation.
Achievement requires preparation. Scripture defines a wise person as one who eagerly seeks knowledge, understanding and instruction (Proverbs 1:5; 4:7; 18:15; 23:12). There are no shortcuts to success that can bypass education and preparation.
3. Work hard.
Success does not come from merely thinking and feeling, but from disciplined effort. Thoughts shape reality only when they direct action and effort. Scripture repeatedly emphasizes the need for diligence: “The soul of a lazy man desires, and has nothing; but the soul of the diligent shall be made rich” (Proverbs 13:4). Desire accomplishes nothing without diligent effort.
4. Seek God’s guidance and blessing.
Help does not come from the universe or from powers within us. It comes from the God who made us and the universe. “In all your ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct your paths” (Proverbs 3:6). When we align our lives with His will, He blesses us according to His purpose. Prayer is not a technique to get what we want—it is a means of drawing close to God and seeking His will (1 John 5:14-15).
These are biblical keys to genuine success—confirmed by Scripture and experience.
Beware of philosophies such as manifestation, which promise effortless results or encourage reliance on one’s own inner power. And be extra cautious when such ideas are gilded in misused biblical language.
True success flows from wisdom, diligence and dependence on God—not the human mind or the powers of the universe.
To explore more biblical principles of success, read “How to Be Successful.”